A business split (Betriebsaufspaltung) exists where a property-holding enterprise makes an essential business asset of considerable importance to the management of an operating enterprise available to that enterprise for use, and a uniform business policy can be enforced in both enterprises. These interdependence through assets and control mean that the property-holding enterprise’s letting activity is deemed to be commercial in its own right. However, the extended trade tax deduction under Section 9 no. 1 sentence 2 of the German Trade Tax Act (Gewerbesteuergesetz; GewStG) is then unavailable. Subject to certain conditions, this deduction exempts income from the management and use of an enterprise’s own real estate from trade tax. In its decision dated August 13, 2026 (case no. III R 12/25), the German Federal Fiscal Court (Bundesfinanzhof; BFH) had to determine whether the letting of roof areas by property-holding enterprises to operating enterprises for the generation and feed-in of solar power is of essential importance and thus gives rise to a business split.


Facts

A housing company made roof areas available to its second-tier subsidiary, in which it held a 100 % interest through an intermediate holding company. The companies formed a two-tier trade tax group (gewerbesteuerliche Organschaft). The second-tier subsidiary primarily provided intra-group real estate services and performed financing functions. It also operated photovoltaic installations on roofs belonging to the housing company and to third parties, feeding the electricity into the public grid. It generated no revenue from this activity in 2008; in 2009 and 2010, the activity accounted for 0.38 % and 0.71 %, respectively, of its total revenue. The tax office denied the housing company the extended trade tax deduction on the grounds that a business split existed. Fiscal Court Düsseldorf took a different view and largely upheld the company’s claim.


Decision and assessment by the BFH

The BFH confirms that no business split existed. Although the indirect shareholding established an interdependence through control, and the rights to use the roof areas could, in principle, also establish an interdependence through assets, those rights did not constitute essential business assets in this case.

Given its share of revenue, electricity generation was of only minor economic significance to the second-tier subsidiary, which primarily operated as a service company, and was not essential to its other business activities. Its core business could have continued without restriction in the absence of this ancillary activity. Electricity generation could also have continued on a smaller scale on the roofs rented from third parties. The assessment must be made solely from the operating enterprise’s perspective, rather than by reference to the property-holding enterprise’s or the group’s interest in green electricity.

The case law on branch operations does not lead to a different conclusion: it is not sufficient for an asset to be essential only to a segment that is insignificant within the business as a whole. Rather, the decisive factor is the asset’s economic importance to the operating enterprise’s business as a whole.

Unlike Fiscal Court Düsseldorf, however, the BFH considers that an adjustment may be required as a result of the trade tax group. Within a trade tax group, add-backs and deductions may generally be applied only if their effects offset each other. Where rental expenses and rental income have already been offset against each other, the additional extended trade tax deduction must not result in unjustified tax relief. As the roof areas were made available for consideration from 2009 onwards, Fiscal Court Düsseldorf must examine whether the relevant rental income was wrongly included in the extended trade tax deduction and whether rental expenses were wrongly added back at the level of the second-tier subsidiary. The trade tax group alone cannot justify denying the deduction in full in this case, as the housing company did not let all of its properties within the trade tax group.

For 2008, the BFH dismissed the appeal on points of law. For 2009 and 2010, it set aside the decision in respect of the trade tax base amounts and loss determinations and referred the case back to Fiscal Court Düsseldorf.


Notice

For intra-group arrangements involving the provision of roof areas, the importance of the photovoltaic activity to the operating enterprise as a whole and its connection with the core business should be documented. A low share of revenue alone does not provide certainty. If electricity generation expands, the assessment must be reviewed. Where a trade tax group exists, potential adjustments to the extended trade tax deduction and to add-backs must be considered independently of that assessment. A finding that no business split exists therefore does not guarantee that the full amount of the extended trade tax deduction will be available.

This article was written by

Roland Speidel
Certified Tax Advisor, Lawyer, Director, National Office Tax & Legal
Marina Leker
Certified Tax Advisor, Manager, National Office Tax & Legal